Saturday, 6 August 2016

Hearthstone: Karazhan, the Final Batch

 Hoo boy, what a doozy. We got twenty-four cards revealed in a stream yesterday, which happened literally while I was reviewing the previous twenty-or-so cards that trickled down from Blizzard over the past week. So I took some time to let the cards sink in, and see the expansion as a whole. Karazhan’s cards as far as balance and meta-relevancy goes doesn’t seem to be as awesome and all-important like League of Explorers or Curse of Naxxramas. I feel like Karazhan will probably end up being more similar to the Blackrock Mountain expansion, spawning a bunch of new archetypes with several individually cool cards… but Blackrock Mountain at least had the dragon theme throughout the expansion. Karazhan… is just weird. It pushes certain archetypes (discard Warlock, beast Druid, thief Rogue, dragon Paladin, secret Hunter and honestly secrets in general, spell-focused decks) and gives tools for several new ones, has a couple of cool legendaries and unique-effect cards, but I dunno, I don’t feel [i]that[/i] enthused for the set? New cards and new content is more than welcome, and I will be sinking all my gold into the adventure, but I’m highly doubtful that it will shake the metagame the way that League of Explorers did. Or maybe I’m wrong. Well, let me review the 24 new cards now and worry about the meta later…


Spirit Claws: Shamans didn't have any cards shown at all prior to this big batch, and, well... it's an interesting card. 1-mana 1/3 that becomes a 3/3 as long as you have a minion with Spell Damage? Shamans are the only class that can activate this little bonus without wasting a card slot -- I mean, Azure Drake's cool and all, but you're not going to wait until turn 5 to play this card. Shamans have a one in a four chance of activating Spirit Claws' effect with the Wrath of Air Totem summoned from their hero power... but honestly, it's a big random effect since the totem itself can be easily killed off. But if you do get the combo to work, and have a 3/3 weapon swinging around by turn two and basically own the board the way that Warriors do with Fiery War Axe, it could be decent. Certainly a lot better than Cursed Blade. Ultimately, though, I think it's way too volatile and it could be reduced back into its 1/3 form quite easily. Shamans are in a spot where they have way too many good cards in their aggro, midrange and evolve decks, and Spirit Claws competes with cards like Tunnel Trogg, Totem Golem and Lightning Bolt as part of the Shaman early game options... and if you're trying hard to make this work (by lobbing in two-mana Spell Damage minions like Bloodmage Thalnos or Kobold Geomancer) it doesn't work all that well in Shamans.

EDIT: This bit was snuck in around, oh, late September. I was totally, totally wrong about Spirit Claws. It's as powerful, if not more powerful, than Tunnel Trogg, because, well, a 3/3 weapon for 1 mana isn't anything to sneeze about. And the fact that it gives Shaman two one-mana drops that can potentially go from 1/3 to 2/3-3/3 by turn two is just insane. It's a 25% chance that you roll a spell damage totem, true, but the presence of a single Bloodmage Thalnos, or indeed rolling spell damage totems with Tuskarr Totemics, makes this thing just absolutely devastating and easily going to be Tunnel Trogg's replacement once he rotates out of standard.

Arcane Anomaly: In addition to having a cool-looking piece of artwork, the Arcane Anomaly is a one-mana 2/1 that gains 1 health every time you cast a spell. I don't really think it will see play... compared to Mana Wyrm, Flamewaker and Violet Teacher, all cards that benefit every time you cast a spell, gaining one health is just honestly not that appealing. The Mana Wyrm definitely outclasses it entirely. Being a neutral card and being dirt cheap means that it might probably find a home in some more exotic classes -- as a combo activator in a spell-centric Rogue deck, maybe? I dunno. It's a card that I don't really see being played a lot after the initial Karazhan craze, though some spell-heavy decks might include him as the one-drop as opposed to Argent Squire or something. 

Avian Watcher: For whatever reason we're getting a lot of Secret synergy cards in this expansion, and I'm a big iffy considering how scummy Mad Scientist and Mysterious Challenger both were. Avian Watcher is a 5-mana 3/6 that becomes a 4/7 with Taunt if you control a secret. It's quite good, actually... a five mana Twin Emperor that has a condition is great value, comparable to a Fen Creeper with +1/+1 or a Sludge Belcher that combines all its stats in one card. It can probably find a home in Freeze Mage decks, which like to have Taunt minions and already run Ice Block and Ice Barrier anyway. I'm a bit iffy on the long-term playability of the card, though... it seems a bit too conditional to trigger, and some secrets, well, are triggered way too easily. Hunters' especially.

Maelstrom Portal: The third Portal spell revealed after Mage's awesome-in-arena Firelands Portal and Druid's pretty-fucking-awesome Moonglade Portal, the Maelstrom Portal is exclusive to Shamans and... kind of underwhelming. Again, mind you, not that Shaman need more game-breaking cards. But Maelstrom Portal is basically Arcane Explosion (2 mana deal 1 damage to all enemy minions) with the added caveat of summoning a random one-drop. Which is a nice little mana efficiency thing, but ultimately not that impactful compared to dropping a Totem Golem. It's a nice alternate board clear compared to Lightning Storm, but Arcane Explosion very rarely sees any play, and I don't think Maelstrom Portal will see much play either. As the stream shows, the Portal cards can actually summon outside of your class -- which was ambiguous -- so in Maelstrom Portal's case it's to its benefit because all the cool one-mana Warlock minions are yours to summon if you are blessed by the RNG god.

EDIT: Again, I was wrong about this, because holy fuck Shaman are getting a crapton of cool shit this expansion. It's nowhere as insanely powerful as Spirit Claws, but with Shaman taking a slightly more spell-damage-centric deck by slotting in Bloodmage Thalnos and two Azure Drakes (both of whom are card draw engines to boot), an additional board clear suddenly makes Midrange Shaman such a powerful monster. Maelstrom Portal isn't quite as powerful a board clear as Lightning Storm, but the fact that Shamans can have three to four of these board clears in their deck, plus two copies of Hex, means that they're virtually unmatched, except maybe by Mage, in terms of sheer board-wipe potential. Add that to the already snowbally minions that Shaman has access too, in addition to the extra bonus body that Maelstrom Portal can spawn -- sometimes you even get absolutely great ones like a Mana Wyrm, a Selfless Hero or a Voidwalker, and even the worst 1-mana minion, which is probably like the 1/1 nerfed Abusive Sergeant, doesn't make you cry like getting a Moat Lurker off the Darnassus Portal.

Swashburglar: To help synergize with the Ethereal Peddler, Rogues get a pretty awesome one-mana minion, the Swashburglar, which I think is one of my favourites of the set. He's a one-mana 1/1 that does the Burgle/Huckster effect as a battlecry. Between the Swashburglar, Undercity Huckster, Burgle, Grand Crusader, Gang Up and Nefarian, a Rogue thief deck is starting to show its roots. The Swashburglar is very cheap, too, and at one mana he's definitely great for triggering your combos. He's also a Pirate, too, if that matters... not that any Rogue Pirate deck has really survived the rotation. Regardless it's a pretty neat stealing tool, and a card that feels like it can have a fair amount of potential. It's one of the few one-mana drops for Rogue that isn't bound to some condition like having a weapon or needing a combo to activate. It's definitely similar to Babbling Book, but unlike the Book, Rogues actually can utilize a one-mana 1/1 very well. 

Wicked Witch Doctor: A four-mana 3/4, which is sub-par stats... 3/4 is a statline for an average 3-drop. She has the effect of summoning a random basic totem if you cast a spell. There's a fair bit of these "if you cast a spell" type of cards in this big reveal, but compared to the Arcane Anomaly above, the Wicked Witch Dotor is honestly useless. If it's a random totem, well, that's a different story -- we all know how disgusting Tuskarr Totemic can be if he summons the Totem Golem or the Mana Tide Totem -- but the Wicked Witch Doctor, I think, is just a bad card. It's too slow and has too little stats for its mana cost, I think, compared to a lot of tools that Shamans have... and besides, we all know that Shamans associate four mana with 7/7 and the 3/4 statline with two mana. That's okay, though. Shamans were loved by Blizzard last expansion, it's fine for them to have sub-par cards in this one.

Medivh’s Valet: The final mage card in this expansion, Medivh's Valet has the most hilarious name, and he's a 2-mana 2/3, which is vanilla stats... that does 3 damage if you control a Secret. Yep, more Secret synergy. He's a River Crocolisk that can cast a Darkbomb for free. Is he worth it, and is he worth cutting out cards from freeze mage or tempo mage decks? My gut says no, but he's cheaper and deals damage so that could honestly be useful. But personally I don't see him making a lot of splashes... but Blackwing Corruptor saw a fair amount of play, so this could be a pretty cool and powerful tempo play. 

Arcane Giant: After being denied a giant last expansion, we get a new one here, a 12-mana 8/8 that gets a discount for each spell you've cast this game. And as anyone who's played a Yogg deck knows, you can cast a fair amount of spells and whittling this down to like, a 4-mana 8/8 is decent value... but really, will a spell-centric deck want to play giants? It might help them to gain control of the board even moreso than they already have, but I don't know. On first glance it seems not that good, but I could be wrong. Also why isn't this a mech? Are the arcane golems mechs or not mechs? Zoobot and the Guardian are mechs, but not the Arcane Giant? Not that it matters, mind you, since mech decks are pretty much dead in standard. But hey.

EDIT: I am wrong. Arcane Giants are absolute monstrosities in Yogg decks, and usually Yogg Druids and Yogg Mages. You basically drop two of these motherfuckers down, since Mages in particular don't exactly need too many spells as it turns out -- Babbling Book, Forgotten Torch and Cabalist Tome generate so much additional spells to trigger Yogg-Saron, Flamewakers and Antonidas, that it doesn't matter that you're cutting a Flamestrike or two. And in Druid the sheer buffing potential that they can do is just gross, in addition to being no slouch in the spam-spells department.

Cloaked Huntress: Cloaked Huntress is already good enough with 3-mana 3/4, premium stats, but she makes your Secrets cost 0 while she's on the field. It's not even a 'for this turn' only like Mage's never-played Kirin Tor Mage, where the Hunter is forced to hold on to the Huntress until they have drawn like two or three secrets. But theoretically Hunter decks can now vomit out an entire hand's worth of Explosive, Freezing, Bear, Dart, Snake, Misdirection and Cat Traps without paying any mana. Mind you, though, that they will have to have had the cards in their hand, which is significantly harder to do compared to Mad Scientist fetching them out of your deck and playing them for free. The Cloaked Huntress just allows you to play them for free... but all of them instead of just one. As Mad Scientist and Mysterious Challenger have shown, allowing you to play a crapton of secrets in one turn is insanely great value. I think it'll be good, both in a dedicated Secret Hunter deck (which I think will still just be mainly delaying until the inevitable Call of the Wild turn) and those Yogg-Saron/Lock-and-Load decks. Oh, man, Yogg-and-Load decks with this card can be absolutely batshit insane.

Cat Trick: A new Hunter secret to capitalize on these Secret-synergy cards, Cat Trap Trick punishes your opponent if they casts a spell by summoning a Jungle Panther for free. Jungle Panthers cost 3 mana, so this card, like the Bear Trap, is definitely value. And, man, can you ever do anything to a Hunter now? Attack its face? Explosive Trap. Attack its minions? Snake Trap. And that's if neither of them are Freezing Traps or Misdirections. Use your hero power? Dart Trap. Play a minion? Snipe. Play a spell? Cat Trick. Hunter traps are going to be the masters of mind-games, and summoning a Jungle Panther is definitely a good thing for Hunters, who really like their beasts and their Houndmasters and Kill Commands. We also don't have a lot of cards that counter spells since Loatheb left Standard, so this is definitely more than welcome. Definitely will see play in secret-dedicated Hunter decks, and who knows? Maybe Cat Trick is good enough to join the big three main Hunter traps being played right now -- Freezing, Bear and Explosive. I'm kinda optimistic about this card.

Nightbane Templar: In addition to looking cool with her sweet artwork, the Nightbane Templar is more support for dragon decks (we already got the Netherspire Historian, Book Worm and technically the Curator and Zoobot)... except she's Paladin-exclusive. Sweet! I play a Dragon Paladin deck, and I kind of dislike my opening. Nightbane Templar is a three-mana 2/3, which is sub-par stats, but if you're holding a dragon, you summon two 1/1 Whelps. Comparable to Blackwing Technician in that both are three-mana non-dragons that get a stat boost if you're holding a dragon... Nightbane Templar gains an extra stat point in total compared to Blackwing Technician's 3/5, and if the enemy doesn't have AoE it's a bit hard to clear everything at once (Swipe makes you sad). Plus the 1/1's also benefit from the Steward of Darkshire if you run her in a Dragon Paladin deck for whatever reason, and can help clear boards subjected to Equality. We've seen how stats split up over multiple bodies can be better, and while I don't necessarily think this is strictly better than the Technician -- they're comparable and more or less equal, I think -- the Templar is definitely a cooler looking addition. The Nightbane Templar is definitely worse on those situations that you're forced to play her without activating her effect by a single health point, and a comparison is that the Templar is a Razorfen Hunter (who's never played) who summons an extra 1/1 token. Having dragons on the battlefield is of minimal consequence -- it's the hand you want them in -- so the tokens being dragon don't really matter all too often.

Pantry Spider: The cutest spider in the world is a 3-mana 1/3, which is horrible stats. Yeah, it's a beast, and it has the battlecry of summoning another 1/3, which makes it technically a 3-mana 2/6, split over two bodies. Ultimately, though, it's basically just summoning two good one-drops (Mana Wyrm, Sir Finley, Tunnel Trogg... lots of one-mana 1/3's) with three mana. Hunters will love the Houndmaster/Kill Command potential, but I don't think it's good enough to be played. The Big Bad Wolf seem to be better and more of a threatening board presence, I think, but this isn't a strictly bad card. Sometimes you do want to just swarm the board, and while it's a relatively bad card for zoo Warlocks, it's great for beast-synergy Hunters and Druids, or the Zoobot decks that might be rearing their heads soon. 

Silvermoon Portal: You give a +2/+2 buff and summon a random two-drop minion for four mana. It's basically combining a weaker version of Mark of the Wild, which costs two mana, and the two mana for the minion... which, compared to the other Portal cards is honestly quite inefficient. At three mana it would've been great, but at four mana I think I'd rather have Blessing of Kings. We all know that the two-mana slots have a lot of whiffs from our Shredder piloting days -- an unwanted Doomsayer being chief among them -- though of course there are good ones. I don't think Silvermoon Portal is honestly all that good, just an average, balanced card.

Menagerie Magician: Zoobot's big brother, the Menagerie Magician is the last card in this expansion that supports the triple-tribe-zoobot deck with Curator and Zoobot, and he's a 5-mana 4/4 that gives +2/+2 buffs. While the Zoobot has safer stats for its cost, the Magician has rather crappy stats, but gives bigger buffs. It's a bigger gamble than the Zoobot, in that the return investment if you manage to trigger three buffs is amazing, but if you only get two it's just okay, and if you get one or don't get anything it's a bad card. Definitely going to be played in those zoobot decks, though, I'm sure. Not sure which class is the best for it yet -- the stream used a Paladin with Vilefin Inquisitor so the hero power becomes a Murloc generating machine and the deck can be filled with better beasts and dragons (and Paladins have good dragon synergy), while Druids and Hunters intrinsically have great beasts. I dunno. We'll see.

Priest of the Feast: Our first Priest card is... Priest of the Feast. Which, if revealed during a time when Priest isn't in dire straits, would've been a great, decent, card. I personally don't think Priest is that bad, but it does need some help since the best Priest deck right now is one that involves just stealing all your opponent's cards, and the odd C'Thun or N'Zoth deck or two that just prays it can heal enough in the mid and late game... what Priest needs is a really good one or two-drop that isn't dependent on dragons, and Priest of the Feast... isn't. He's a four-mana 3/6, which is of course premium stats, and he heals your hero for 3 every time you cast a spell, which puts him in the same category of being triggered by spells like the Arcane Anomaly and Wicked Witch Doctor... except, y'know, it's not a card that Priest really needs right now. It's a great, balanced card, but considering the amount of good four-drops that Priests have right now the last thing they need is a semi-good one that competes for the slot, while not doing anything to alleviate the early game pressure Priest is facing.

Deadly Fork: Deadly Fork is a three-mana 3/2 that lobs a (three-mana!) 3/2 weapon to your hand. I loved the idea of picking up the fallen minion and then stabbing your minion with it... and the idea of this Blood Elven rogue just running around with a fork instead of a dagger is hilarious. But it's a bad card, really, and I honestly would've preferred a weapon outright -- what is the point of nerfing Blade Flurry to oblivion if you're not going to add cool Rogue weapons? Deadly Fork's biggest failing, I think, is the fact that you have to re-cast the weapon fork instead of it auto-equipping it for you. It really could've been a four-mana 3/2 with the deathrattle of equipping a 3/2... a 3/2 minion costs two mana, and Fiery War Axe is a 3/2 weapon that costs two mana, so why? Why did Deadly Fork get penalized so much? You spend three mana to drop the minion (which only has as much stats as a two-drop), then spend three mana to equip a weapon that should've only costed two? Damn this card is bad. You're better off playing Southsea Squidface or Deadly Poison.

Onyx Bishop: Our second Priest card is the Onyx Bishop, which, while cool-looking, is basically a vanilla 3-mana minion with 3/4 stats rolled together with the two-mana Resurrect. Which... honestly isn't that good. Resurrect isn't a spectacular card in itself, though the effect is certainly cool, but the fact that it's two mana and a spell means it's cheap enough for you to do something else, and the lack of flexibility that Onyx Bishop has, being a big five mana thing, means that, hey, other than the odd chance of you getting a 4/7 Injured Blademaster back, it's probably going to kind of suck, summoning Northshire Clerics and Wild Pyromancers and whatever the hell Priests play in the early game. The Onyx Bishop really could've been a slightly more value-filled statline or a cheaper mana cost and I still don't think he'll see much play. Honestly, they did so much cool creative shit with the card design for all the other classes, this is just lazily slapping together a Spider Tank and a Resurrect with cheap glue. We could've had his effect be 'Discover a friendly minion that died earlier this game and summon it' with a slight penalty. We could've had him have decent stats like 5/5 and he adds the dead minion to the hand. We could even have had the Priest Thoughtsteal theme (which I hate, by the way) and have him discover a minion, both from yours and your opponent's, that died earlier this game. It's not just m'eh in gameplay, it's so m'eh in design as well.

Purify: Well, Priest of the Feast is an okay card but not what Priest needs right now, while Onyx Bishop felt like a m’eh “let’s combine a spell and a decently-statted minion together” card, hopefully Priest’s third card in this expansion is at least decent, right? The class needs all the help it can get, after all. Purify is… at first I thought this card read ‘silence a minion, draw a card’. The reason Silence (the card, not the effect) is never ran in Priest is that it’s a waste of a card slot and simply silencing a minion without dropping a body on the board the way Spellbreaker and old!Ironbeak Owl did was kind of not what you want a card to do. So for two mana more than Silence you get a single card draw, which isn’t optimal at all considering Priest has access to Northshire Cleric… and then I reread the card and it says silence a friendly minion. And then it's just utterly bad, easily one of the worst cards in the game. Which minion are you going to be happy to silence for two mana? For two mana? Wailing Soul gives you a body and silences all your minions, and he never saw play even with dudes like Zombie Chow and Deathlord being very common cards. I suppose you can use Moat Lurker and Purify to remove a minion... at which point I'm wondering why you aren't running Entomb or the Shadow Words. Ancient Watcher? Eerie Statue? Yeah, 6 mana for a 7/7 and 4 mana for a 4/5, both of which require two cards... the card draw doesn't matter that much because ultimately you're wasting your deck slots with combo pieces that honestly don't offer much of an advantage. What the fuck, this card, really. The only way that I see it being used is if in the future we get a card that says 'Shuffle three Purifies into your enemy's deck". 


Menagerie Warden: Holy shit this card is awesome. Is this the card that Beast Druids finally need to clinch its existence? The Warden is a 6-mana 5/5, which isn't horribad, but it has the battlecry of summoning a copy of a friendly beast. The most obvious curving is from a 4/6 Druid of the Claw on turn 5 straight into a turn 6 play that summons a 5/5 and a 4/6, upon which your opponent just concedes out of frustration. Stranglethorn Tiger is another great 5-mana beast that Beast Druid decks already play. Savage Combatant, Stampeding Kodo, Addled Grizzly and Druid of the Flame are also premium targets, but even if all you get is, like, a 1/3 Pantry Spider it's still pretty decent. Add that to all the cool tools that Beast Druid received over WOTOG (Mark of Y'Shaarj and Fandral Staghelm being primary among them) and in this expansion (Menagerie Warden, plus Zoobot and Menagerie Magician both buffing beasts) might we finally see the fabled Beast Druid deck come into existence? Menagerie Warden seems far, far more impactful than previous attempts to make Beast Druid work like Druid of the Fang, Knight of the Wild and Wildwalker, for sure.

Ironforge Portal: Our final Warrior card after Fool's Bane and Unleash the Taunts is Ironforge Portal, which is a five-mana spell that gives you four armour and summons a four-mana minion. Which is just... value. It's a Shield Block that instead of drawing a card summons a four-mana minion, which is just quite impressive. It's a great card to slot in a fair amount of Warrior decks, and while Warrior decks are generally quite refined and specific, I can see this card being used moderately, if only for the chance to summon a fucking 7/7 Flamewreathed Faceless out of it... though the variance on four drops is quite massive. You can get, like, a Dreadsteed or a Faceless Shambler or a non-battlecried Twilight/Midnight Drake. But most of the time four-drops are decent. The aforementioned 7/7, plus C'Thun's Chosen, Ancient Shade, Murloc Knight, Sen'jin, Bloodhoof Brave, Cult Master... At worst it's a Shieldmaiden that's cheaper but gives a weaker body and slightly less armour, and Shieldmaiden is played everywhere. 

Runic Egg: One mana 0/2 that has Loot Hoarder's deathrattle. It's just bad. No one's going to pop this thing for you, and unlike Dragon or Nerubian Eggs you don't really get a board out of losing the thing. Loot Hoarder gives you a body and has the identical effect as Runic Egg for a single mana more. I don't think this card will see play, it's just bad in my opinion.

Moat Lurker: Oh shit, Devour! From Warcraft III! Well, kinda. Moat Lurker 'eats' a minion, removing it from play, and upon the Lurker's death the minion is returned. Kudos for the very interesting card design, and Moat Lurker can be used offensively -- to temporarily remove an enemy minion (and permanently if you panda or silence this dude) or to trigger a deathrattle on one of your own. It counts towards N'Zoth, so Moat Lurker on things like Sylvannas Windrunner, Cairne Bloodhoof, Tirion Fordring, Anub'arak and all those dream deathrattle legendaries is absolutely insane. But taking a look at the card itself... the Moat Lurker has some truly atrocious stats at being a six-mana 3/3 that you probably will never want to use him for removal, and only on your own minion because wasting 6 mana to only temporarily remove an enemy minion is just bad. But as a combo piece to trigger deathrattles and N'Zoth effects, Moat Lurker is such a unique card that I think it'll be tried out a couple of times. I know I will. Whether it's just a cool effect that might not work (*cough*Varian*Y'Shaarj*cough*) or if it'll actually boost N'Zoth even more obscenely, we'll see.

Arcanosmith: A four-mana 3/2 that summons a 0/5 with Taunt. At first glance it's bad. It's like a Bloodfen Raptor that summons a slightly stronger Shieldbearer, which calculates to three mana. Yeah, the shield token that Arcanosmith summons has a health more than Shieldbearer, but it's still ultimately a zero mana Taunt, which does nothing to delay your opponent other than maybe tank a hit or two. A 3/7 with Taunt would be insane, but this isn't it. Taunts with one health already don't see play -- the Mogu'shan Warden is only borderline decent thanks to some possible Inner Fire hijinks. Bolster decks, maybe, with Protect the King? But then why wouldn't you run Bloodhoof Brave instead? So yeah. The art and concept of creating a magical force-shield thing is cool, but Arcanosmith joins the Thespian, Onyx Bishop and Runic Egg at trying to be variations and combinations of older cards that is just kinda bad.

Violet Illusionist: Holy shit, this card. 3-mana 4/3 is premium stats already, even if it's slightly worse than 3/4, but she gives your hero immunity during your turn. Obviously it protects against those Explosive Traps, and Warlocks can afford to summon Pit Lords, Flame Imps and trade with Wrathguard with no repercussion -- Pit Lord's actually decent in this regard with the Illusionist active -- but the main appeal with this? Weapon trading. Hunters, Warriors, Paladins and Shamans cheer for being able to kill minions with absolutely no repercussions. Especially Warrior. Remember Fool's Bane, the 3/4 Weapon that can attack as many times as you want in a turn as long as you don't hit a hero? Yeah, well, you can just whack something like a Ysera or Soggoth four times and not take damage, or just wipe a board of Giants and Twin Emperors and not take damage. Shamans can get even more obscene board control with Doomhammers. Warriors already don't care about damage taken while weapon-bashing, this makes them even more obscene in that regard. Violet Illusionist is kind of crap if you don't have some insane weapon combo prepared in your deck, but with proper cards, man... it's going to be awesome. 

So to recap, here's what I think how the cards will end up being, rated in five categories...


  • Awesome: [Absolutely great, things that make powerful decks even more powerful] Barnes, Menagerie Warden, Cloaked Huntress, Cat Trick, Swashburglar
  • Good: [Decent with some setup and whatnot, might spawn new archetypes] Netherspite Historian, Zoobot, Violet Illusionist, Book Wyrm, The Curator, Medivh the Guardian, Enchanted Raven, Moonglade Portal, Kindly Grandmother, Medivh's Valet, Kara Kazham, Fool's Bane, Ironforge Portal
  • Average: [Okay card, but relatively outclassed by other cards] Arcane Anomaly, Menagerie Magician, Arcane Giant, Prince Malchezaar, Avian Watcher, Firelands Portal, Babbling Book, Nightbane Templar, Ivory Knight, Priest of the Feast, Ethereal Peddler, Spirit Claws, Malchezaar's Imp, Silverware Golem, Protect the King
  • Filler: [...might be decent in arena?] Pompous Thespian, Pantry Spider, Silvermoon Portal, Onyx Bishop, Wicked Witchdoctor, Maelstrom Portal
  • Bad: [Free dust] Runic Egg, Arcanosmith, Moat Lurker, Moroes, Purify, Deadly Fork


That's it for the review of individual cards. The entire set is out, and we got a couple of very interesting cards, though kind of a shame that there are some really underwhelming cards the overall quality of the cards seem to be average to above-average... though like everyone else I'm honestly a bit miffled about Priest getting the middle finger. What, couldn't have swapped Book Wyrm as a Priest card and throw Purify away? Here's my predictions about how this will impact the meta:

  • Druids get the Beast synergy that has been built up since the start of the game, and a very excellent Portal spell.
  • Hunters might finally branch out of midrange with their insane secret synergies, though they did get Pantry Spider and Kindly Grandmother as support for Beast decks.
  • Mages get a cool arena spell, a weird little minion that generates spells and a secret synergy minion. It helps to boost existing spell and tempo decks and opens up secret synergies, too.
  • Paladins get a pretty cool dragon synergy card, which combined with Book Wyrm and the Zoobot buddies might actually help dragon Paladin be great again. Ivory Knight is also a pretty cool card that makes Paladins even more unkillable with Forbidden Healing in the game.
  • Rogues get a shitty fork, but the two cards that support a burgle/thief playstyle look very interesting. While I doubt that it'll be competitive, Burgle Rogue definitely will be a far funner deck to play than Milkshake Priest.
  • Shamans get a lot of tools in the last expansion, but even the cards they got here aren't half bad (well, the Witch Doctor isn't one that'll see play, I think) just kind of overshadowed by Flamewreathed Faceless, Tuskarr Totemic, Tunnel Trogg and the rest.
  • Warlocks start to branch out, and like Beast Druid a lot of synergies for the discard mechanic which they're trying to build up, are finally introduced. A cool late game spell might actually be a decent finisher for zoo Warlock decks, though like Shaman, Warlocks are already in a good spot, these are just nice little presents for it.
  • Warriors get a couple of deceptively simple but potentially insane spells, plus the absolutely fun-looking Fool's Bane, which is one of the coolest concepts they have for the game. Warriors don't need anything good at all, dominating the metagame as they do, but hey, the cards look really cool.
  • Priest... RIP Priest, I'm afraid. One of its cards is outright the worst card of the expansion, and the other two are mediocre at best. Compared to, hell, even Rogue, where two of its cards at least support an archetype... Wow, Priest just got shafted real hard.

Friday, 5 August 2016

Hearthstone: More Karazhan Cards!

 Yeah, I like to talk about Hearthstone, and there's all sorts of new expansion/adventure hype and stuff. So yeah, I'm gonna talk about it a bit. Since the announcement last week several more new cards have been revealed, and I'm basically going to be making this a weekly thing until Karazhan releases proper some time next week. Anyway, from relative chronological order of card reveal, way back from the little dudes at the beginning:


EDIT: Fuck, there was a huge stream that happened like a couple of hours that revealed literally the rest of the expansion. Well, enjoy these slightly older cards while I scramble to review the new ones.


Malchezzar's Imp:
It's a Warlock card, and the first Demon minion since, shit, the Grand Tournament? It's a one-mana 1/3 that has the effect of drawing a card whenever you discard a card. Which... honestly isn't that good. Drawing a card isn't a terribly big problem for Warlocks, and the discarding gimmick is kind of terrible if the only card that really makes you want to discard cards is Fist of Jaraxxus. Unless we get cards that go 'Discover a card you discarded earlier this game' or 'summon a random demon equal to the cost of the card you discard' or some big tempo swing like that, discard decks won't work. The reason why discarding and graveyard mechanics are so powerful in Yu-Gi-Oh and M:TG is because those games have cards that allow you to summon things from the graveyard, and without the ability to 'cheat' the mana cost of summoning large minions, Discard is just going to kind of be something that no one really will use, especially since Warlock has so many better tools. And Malchezzar's Imp just fall short of all the already-awesome one-mana drops that Warlock has, so he won't be making Zoo Warlock deck lists either. I dunno. You can make this work with Succubus and Darkshire Librarian, I suppose, but whether it's a good deck... nah.

Babbling Book: A one-mana 1/1 for Mages that adds a random Mage spell to your hand. It's not going to replace Mana Wyrm as the quintessential one-drop because Mana Wyrm is awesome, but the Babbling Book adds a card to your hand and doesn't thin your deck. It's quite useful, and a cheaper and weaker version of things like Cabalist's Tome and Nexus-Champion Saraad. It's got the cutest art ever, though. I like this, and I'm sure to try it out a little in my Yogg-Saron mage deck, but I am highly doubtful it'll actually be that good.

Book Wyrm: A six-mana 3/6 isn't the best thing in the world, even if it's a Dragon. Twilight Guardian got the 3/6 stat line (admittedly with Taunt) and he costs only four mana. So Book Wyrm better have a good effect... and it basically casts Shadow Word: Pain if you're holding a dragon in your hand. I like Blackwing Corruptor better -- a 5-mana 5/4 that shoots three damage if you're holding a dragon -- because its stat line and damage flexibility works far better than Shadow Word: Pain. Even if you're considering that he's a 4-mana 3/6 because he's bundled with SW:P that costs 2 mana, it's still kinda bad because it's conditional. And for six mana, well, I dunno. I don't really like him, but maybe he can be a decent one-off removal tool? Best artwork of the expansion, probably, though. It's a card that a lot of people swear will be super-good and be super gamebreaking, but I dunno. As someone who really likes playing Dragon decks, I don't see adding more than one of these into my deck. It's a better six-drop than Scaled Nightmare and Volcano Drake, that's for sure, but whether it's a better fit than, say Draconic Crusher, which is also as conditional as the Book Wyrm... I dunno. We'll have to see. I'd say that it's mostly good, just with the potential with whiffing... though compared to Draconic Crusher, the potential of removing a threat instead of just adding a bunch of stats certainly can be more valuable.

Moroes: Moroes is weird, as is appropriate for Medivh's butler. He's a 3-mana 1/1 with Stealth that generates a free 1/1 token every turn. How valuable is it to have a free Paladin hero power every turn as long as you don't mind paying the initial 3-mana to do basically nothing? Hogger is basically better -- he summons a 2/2 with Taunt every turn -- and you don't see him played, like, ever. It's definitely going to be super valuable in token decks like Savage Roar/Mark of the Wild Druid decks, or in Paladin decks with Steward of Darkshire, but it's one of those cards that I think is honestly kind of shit.


Prince Malchezaar: Ah, I think we have my favourite card of the expansion right here. I love the Eredar, and to see our... third...? I think third. We've got Lord Jaraxxus and the Wrathguard. Yeah, third Eredar in the game is pretty damn boss. But Malchezaar is a neutral demon with Pit Fighter stats -- 5 mana for 5/6, but at the start of your game he'll lob five extra Legendary cards into your deck. Which is like whaaaat. That was the initial plan, apparently, for Y'Shaarj or N'Zoth or some of the old gods, the virtue of owning the card in your deck will allow you to do something crazy at the beginning of the game like immediately replacing your hero or be locked at 5-mana permanently or something. Prince Malchezaar doesn't do something so insanely game-breaking, but he shuffles five extra Legendaries into your deck, while being honestly kinda just average himself in the battlefield. But Malchezaar's effect is... awesome! I love it.

Aggro decks and Combo decks don't want this dude because it'll bloat their deck and prevent them from reaching the cards they want, but as someone who primarily plays Control decks at the moment I would definitely love a decently-statted Legendary that adds five extra cards into my deck. Hell, five extra cards would be decent, but for them to be Legendary? Yeah, there are a lot of shitty Legendaries out there (the two Pagles, Executus, Lorewalker Cho, Rend Blackhand and Moroes being the ones you'll dread to get) and a lot that you probably can't work with if you don't have synergies in your deck (C'Thun, Twin Emperor Vek'lor, Aviana, Kragg, Chillmaw, that goblin pirate)... but five legendaries, man! The advantage that you'll get for throwing in like, Ragnaros or Sylvanas or Tirion or Thaurissan or Ysera would be awesome, but even having things like Gruul, Eydis Darkbane, Cho'gall, Rhonin, the Muklas, the Deathwings or Dreadscale can help even out the battlefield and be, y'know, quite decent. Moreover it also gives you card advantage, which is great in a control game... but despite initially seeming like an easy auto-include in most decks, a lot of decks nowadays are very streamlined, so despite his pretty cool effect Malchezaar isn't probably going to see a lot of upper-ladder play.

Unleash the Taunts Protect the King!: Warriors' version of Unleash the Hounds, it's basically identical, just replacing Charge with Taunt. Three mana, summon a 1/1 with Taunt for every enemy minion. It's a bit odd for a Warrior to have an Unleash style of card, because, well, 1/1's die to Ravaging Ghouls and Whirlwinds and all those deal one damage to everyone effects that Warriors like to use. On the other hand, a board filled with Taunters and then you drop a Bolster, holy shit, then suddenly you just summoned an entire board's worth of 3/3's with Taunt and against a Zoolock that's no joke. It's not a card that all Warrior decks will use, but I like this card.

Kara Kazham!: For five mana, you summon a 1/1, 2/2 and a 3/3. It's got a very fun Disney-esque feel to it, and, well, Warlocks do love vomiting out minions to the board. More Power Overwhelming targets, more Abusive Sergeant targets, yadda yadda. Whether it'll be too slow for Zoolock lists -- which I don't think it is -- or if it'll be Warlocks' new quintessential Call of the Wild style finisher, well, we'll have to see. Definitely better than Malchezaar's Imp, that's for sure. It's comparable to the new post-nerf Force of Nature, except one mana cheaper and splitting the stats apart... which actually means that it's miles better, because there's no single card except Flamestrike and the 'kill everything' super-expensive Warlock spells that can clear all three minions cleanly. Swipe leaves a 2/1 on the board, Consecration leaves a 1/1 on the board, Fan of Knives is just sad... and anyone who faces off against zoo Warlocks will know the amount of work that Warlocks can do with just even a single 1/1 token. Power Overwhelming, Defender of Argus, Dire Wolf Alpha... et cetera, et cetera. Ultimately I still think it's going to be way too slow for zoolock lists, but it's a cool card that I really kind of dismissed the first time I saw it.

Pompous Thespian: A neutral 2-mana 3/2 with Taunt. It's a better version of both the Frostwolf Grunt (one more attack) and comparable to the Ironfur Grizzly (one less mana, but one less health and not a beast). It's... it's a card, I guess? I don't mind simple, 'boring' cards like this. A lot of people give the Thespian a lot of flak for 'wasting' a slot that Blizzard could've used for a more interesting and meta-breaking card, but I've dabbled in other TCGs before, and, well, honestly having just one 'boring' filler card that's just, well, a bundle of stats honestly isn't the end of the world.

Zoobot: 3-mana 3/3 Mech that gives a Dragon, a Beast and a Murloc +1/+1. It's super-valuable if you can get it to work, I mean, some decks still run Shattered Sun Cleric and this is theoretically triple the value you get off of the Shattered Sun Cleric, but even with the Curator how often do you have all three on board the deck? Nah, this one I think will fall by the wayside, while the Curator at least has the card-fetching and taunt thing going. Zoobot is just... well, not that great. It's awesome if you get him to go off on at least two minions, but how likely that is, well... At the end of the day it's kinda-sorta decent in Arena if you can get its effect to pop off once or twice, but how often does that happen? I don't really think he's going to work at all that well. It's a decent little buffing tool, but while he looks fun I think he'll be cut out of more refined decks.

Medivh the Guardian: I've been waiting for the Heroes of Warcraft to be turned into card form. I mean, what's stopping the likes of Malfurion and Khadgar and Rexxar and Liadrin from being minions of their own? Jaina already sort of is a card with Mirror Image, Shadowcaster is technically Valeera('s shadow) and Liadrin and Gul'dan are technically the characters depicted in Shattered Sun Cleric and Blackwing Corruptor respectively. But none actually specifically depict the character until, well, we get Medivh, the Guardian. He's differentiated from the hero Medivh by being a hip, younger, non-demon-possessed, disco-ball version of the character. Medivh is... an eight-mana 7/7 that equips Atiesh, which is his staff. Eight-mana 7/7 have historically been iffy. We've got Gruul, Rhonin and Force-Tank Max as comparable ones, and Gruul technically ends up a 9/9 on your next turn if he survives. Force-Tank Max has an additional Divine Shield and the Mech tag, but it's a non-legendary minion. Rhonin has the Deathrattle of adding three copies of Arcane Missiles to your hand, but you almost never see him being played. Medivh better have some awesome effect... and he equips Atiesh, which is a 1/3 Weapon that has a passive effect that triggers and spends durability -- something that the fandom has been doing ever since I discovered fanmade cards with tomes, shields and staves and all sorts of non-aggressive equipment.

Atiesh is slightly different in that you can clonk people with the raven staff if you really want to... 1-attack weapons have been used before, though it's probably going to have minimal effect on turn 8. But the flexibility (and the chance of being Upgraded or Bloodsail Cultist'd in Warrior) is cool. Its effect is basically a copy of the Summoning Stone, except that you don't have to spend 6-mana to get a crappy 0/6 minion. Blizzard really wants that effect to become a thing, don't they? It's a cool effect, though I don't think it's one that really justifies putting Medivh into your deck beyond seeing how cool it ends up being. It can find a decent home in any Yogg deck, I suppose, and the 7/7 body plus 1/3 weapon is considerable enough for eight mana (basically War Golem + a weaker Light's Justice) even without the effect. And you do get the effect. Time will tell if it's great like the initially-deceptively-simple Dr. Boom, or if it's a cool effect that doesn't work in most decks like Chromaggus.


Silverware Golem: Ah, finally, a card that benefits from being discarded! With only Fist of Jaraxxus as the only candidate as a card you'll be happy to discard, we have a dearth of cards for a discard deck. I mean, we have great cards that cause the discard effect (Succubus, Doomguard, Darkshire Librarian), we have cards that cause benefit if cards are discarded when they're on the field (Malchezaar's Imp, Tiny Knight of Evil) but this is only the second card that actually benefits from being discarded. That said, though, is summoning a 3/3 for free that big of a tempo swing? It's crap if you pay the full 3 mana, and it's going to be a dead card for the off chance that the Doomguard will discard this thing when you play it. I dunno. I don't think discard decks will really pan out that well if Silverware Golem is the type of card that supports the archetype. This is the last Warlock card to be revealed with Kara Kazham and Malchezaar's Imp, so... yeah, it's a good start to the discard mechanic, but I don't think it's enough to make it work.

Netherspite Historian: Netherspite Historian is an effect I have wanted since, like, forever. She's a 2-mana 1/3, which is kind of shitty stats (though better than Museum Curator, who has a comparable effect) because 1/3 is something you'd expect from a one-mana drop. But if you're holding a Dragon, the Netherspite Historian lets you discover a Dragon and guess what? Dragons are generally good, and the worst Dragon cards (Dragonkin Sorcerer, Hungry Dragon, Nozdormu, Scaled Nightmare, Fairy Dragon) are at least average or playable. The important distinction is that you discover the card, which means you decide what goes into your hand. The problem with discovering dragons is that, well, so much of them is in the late-game category of 6-mana and 9-mana, that discovering them at turn two is a bit... iffy. Though Dragon decks have historically been kinda struggling for a good early game. Priests have got Wyrmrest Agents, which are... okay-ish, and I play Fairy Dragon in my Dragon Paladin decks, and they're decent if easily swapped out for something like this. I dunno. We'll see. Maybe she'll be a one-off? Maybe you take out one of the Blackwing Techies for her? I like Dragon decks so all these new dragon synergy cards like Book Wyrm, Curator and this card really appeals to me. Hopefully Nightbane gets made into a really cool dragon legendary.

Moonglade Portal: The second of the five portal spells, Moonglade Portal is exclusive to Druids and, wow, it's a lot more efficient than Firelands Portal. Granted, Firelands Portal lets you do damage, and free damage is something Mages can definitely abuse, but Moonglade Portal is one mana cheaper than Firelands Portal, summons a six-drop instead of a five-drop... the catch? You heal for six instead of dealing five damage. It's a card that might be a great one-off recovery option... Healing Touch and the nerfed Ancient of Lore aren't great recovery options, so this is definitely a great one that helps out by doing two things at once -- summoning a six-drop and healing at the same time. I think there are less 'crappy-stat-but-great-battlecry' minions in the six-mana slot compared to the five-mana slot. The only really bad ones I can think of is Corrupted Seer, Nerubian Prophet, Justicar Trueheart and Book Wyrm (3/6 isn't the worst, but when you compare it to the 5/5's and 6/7's you can get...). But the thing is, Sylvannas Winrunner, Emperor Thaurissan and Cairne Bloodhoof, three of the best legendaries in the game, are in the six-mana slot. Who else is in the six-mana slot? Great stuff like the Dark Arakkoa, Hogger, Argent Commander, Gadgetzan Auctioneer, Sunwalker... and in the six-mana slot, most of the battlecry whiffs like Faceless Summoner or Reno Jackson or Sideshow Spell-eater have, like a 5/5 or 4/6 statline, when they're not being 6/7's and 7/6's. So I think it's a bit more valuable, board control wise, than Firelands Portal? On the other hand, the Firelands Portal probably helps clear a minion while Moonglade Portal just gives you healing. I dunno. It looks really good.

Fool's Bane: Warriors get a very cool and unique weapon. Five-mana 3/4 is basically the Rogues' Assassin's Blade, which is already a decent weapon, but you can attack as many times as you want... but not to the face. Which might be the deal-breaker here. Gorehowl has a bit of a similar restriction where the weapon will finally lose durability and break (unless you Upgraded it or Bloodsail Cultist'd it) when you attack the hero, but Fool's Bane outright can only clear minions. It's in Warrior, which, among the weapon-using classes, is the one who totally doesn't give a shit about their health total because of their insane armoring-up cards. So dealing 12 damage for five mana, and damage you can control too, is quite decent value. Whether it's good enough to be put in the established Warrior decks, though, remains to be seen. Warrior decks have a lot of really great cards that Fool's Bane will need to compete with (Fiery War Axe, for one), and whether this will be the new Death's Bite or just a dud weapon like Tentacles-for-Arms... I dunno. I'm leaning towards the former, really? It's such a cool and unique effect, though, and, man, it's definitely going to be a great murderer of zoo. Assuming, of course, the zoo deck hasn't crippled your Warrior by turn 5.

Overall I don't think there's any card that will shake up the meta wildly the way League of Explorers introduced so many deck buildaround cards. We got a lot of great tools for existing archetypes, and some that might encourage the building of new ones, but other than maybe Barnes I don't think any of these cards are anything but 'cool card to slot in X deck' or 'cool card to try out'. I mean, like, the BeastMurGon and discard Warlock decks are the ones that seem to be entirely new, while others are like 'yeah, more support for Dragon decks' and 'look at this weird, cool legendary'. Though we haven't seen like, half of the cards in the set, especially the Class cards. So... we'll wait and see!

Thursday, 28 July 2016

Hearthstone: One Night in Karazhan

 Yay, a new adventure is announced! Quite surprisingly, I'm still not entirely bored with the newest set yet -- by the time that Grand Tournament, League of Explorers and Whispers of the Old Gods showed up the meta has became quite stale, but I honestly am not having that feeling with this batch. Maybe it's the result of having two different metas, or so many deck archetypes that's playable... I dunno. But the next adventure, 'One Night in Karazhan', is set for release in two weeks. For news and details check out Hearthpwn.com and other news sites that'll undoubtedly be more concise. Also I don't wanna just retype everything.


Karazhan is a cool part of the lore, first introduced as a pretty generic mage tower belonging to Medivh that's common in a lot of fantasy fiction, it became extra-prominent when it is released as a dungeon in World of Warcraft, with the ghosts and magical beings that remained within the tower running wild. This version, of course, is a Hearthstone-ified version of the insane yet dark tower, and the within the story of the game apparently we turn back the clock to when Medivh was sane and hip and smashing, and throws a party... yet he disappears for some reason, and we have to go through the Karazhan bosses who run wild (of course) plus, um, a Silverware Golem. Aesthetically Karazhan is awesome and the bits we saw with the new bosses and whatnot all look really cool, and the trailer is pretty bombing too, but while the adventure experience is undoubtedly going to be amazing and awesome, especially with wacky shit like the Chess and Opera Events... let's talk about the cards.

(Young Medivh looks pimp as fuck, by the way)

We're getting 45 new cards, and like League of Explorers two of them will be free upon unlocking the first wing. At this point we're only getting to see seven of them, which is a bit of a shame, but hey.


  • Ivory Knight: It's a Paladin minion, a six-mana 4/4, based on the Chess Event, but it allows you to discover a spell (like Ethereal Conjurer) and, most importantly, heal for its cost. Paladin has became the premier healer class with the addition of Forbidden Healing and Ragnaros the Lightlord in Whispers of the Old Gods, and there's still neutral healing options like Cult Apothecary and Earthen Ring Farseer around. With Paladins being quite decent in the value and control games, getting to do two things at once -- heal and discover a potentially devastating spell -- it's definitely far better than I initially thought it is. And a 4/4 body is pretty balanced, yet nothing to sneeze at either. It's a cool and unique design, if nothing else.
  • Kindly Grandmother: 2-mana 1/1 with a Deathrattle that summons a 3/2. And it's a beast! Far more mana-efficient than the Infested Wolf, and kind of a weaker but cheaper version of that Twilight Summoner dude. It's super-flavourful with the wolf grandmama becoming a monster upon 'dying' and shedding its disguise, and, wow. Deathrattle Hunter didn't exactly take off because Midrange Hunter was so insanely good, but this will benefit both Deathrattle and Midrange Hunters for sure. Also both the Grandmother and the summoned Big Bad Wolf are both beasts, so that's additional synergy with tings like Houndmaster. I just hope they didn't go too overboard with Deathrattles again, but with N'Zoth around I'm sure the ones they make from here on out will be a lot more balanced. It's like, well, they know what cards are good, but they know releasing them as Neutrals will make them auto-includes in the way that Haunted Creeper and Piloted Shredder were, so I wouldn't be surprised if we see a resurgence of more older Naxx or GvG cards in new forms.
  • Ethereal Peddler: 5-mana 5/6 with a battlecry that gives a 2-mana discount for cards from other classes in your hand. So this comboes well with Undercity Huckster, Nefarian and Burgle... and you might think that it's a bit too specific because the cards you get from those cards might not even be good... but a 5-mana 5/6 isn't a bad card, really, and discounts are very useful for a Rogue. Ultimately he might just be too slow and unwieldy, though his stats isn't really bad maybe the other Rogue card from this Adventure might give another steal effect? I definitely will try to make a deck out of the 'steal' mechanic. Oh, by the way, if a Priest Thoughtsteals this card, man... otherwise, though, it's a very gimmicky card. Hell if it doesn't look fun, though.
  • Enchanted Raven: 1-mana 2/2 Beast. Yeah, Druids don't want to be outdone by Shaman's 4-mana 7/7. It's a lot less insane than Flamewreathed Faceless, for sure, and possibly less impactful, since Druids like to just skip a lot of the early turns and go straight to turn 4 and 5... and Living Roots already does the same thing, except it splits the 2/2 stats across two bodies (rendering it susceptible to Arcane Explosion or Fan of Knives) with the added flexibility of being able to deal direct damage if needed, doing both effects with Fandral and triggering Yogg-Saron. The Raven looks good initially but I think I still prefer Living Roots? It'll be graet in Beast Druid, which we might reach... eventually. Don't think this is the card that'll do it, though.
  • Firelands Portal: 7-mana spell. Deal 5 damage, summon a random 5-mana minion. Holy shit this card is awesome. It's nothing to sneeze at -- you're basically getting a 5-mana minion, and a 2-mana 5-damage which, when you consider how much Fireball and Frostbolt are priced, is insane value. And yes, the 5-mana minion is random... but there are a lot of great 5-mana minions, as my Forbidden Shaping plays have shown me. A quick look through the Standard list shows that the only real losers are the untransformed Druid of the Claw, Faceless Manipulator, Validated Doomsayer, BGH and Ram Wrangler. And yeah, a lot of the other dudes don't have their battlecries activate, but you get generally a 5/5, 5/4 or 6/3 body and that's half-decent considering the additional damage you deal with the spell. And sometimes you get an Earth Elemental or Doomguard and just win the game. It's a spell, too, so it'll be great in Yogg decks, and in arena, man, as if Mages need more OP common cards. At a glance it appears to be great in arena and semi-decent in constructed. It's apparently a series of portal cards a la Forbidden spells? That's cool. I've always loved 'set' cards. 
  • Barnes: 4-mana 3/4 that summons a 1/1 copy of a random minion in your deck. It's basically a random, cheaper Shadowcaster, except you can't target the minion. You do get it for free, though, so maybe it'll be useful? I dunno. Pulling out things like Y'Shaarj or Ragnaros or Sylvanas or Tirion or Antonidas would be awesome, but Shadowcaster's great because you can combo it and choose what you want to copy... and if Barnes pulls out a Battlecry minion then it just kinda sucks because you ultimately just get a Yeti's worth of stats with four mana. You don't see a lot of Herald Volazj being played, after all, and I don't think Barnes will be played too much either. I really liked the lore reason, though, where Barnes the opera master summons an 'actor' to play the card in your deck. A Deathrattle N'Zoth deck would be awesome. Unlike Y'Shaarj, he won't waste the battlecry of the N'Zoth he pulls out and he doesn't 'waste' the minion, but if he does pull out a good Deathrattle minion like Sylvanas or Cairne or Xaril or Anub'arak, well, you're in for a treat. I don't know, a lot of people point out how awesome if he pulls out Malygos or Y'Shaarj or Ragnaros on turn 4, but eh. It's something that's kind of a coin toss, I think? He might be really, really good, or be really, really bad. It's one that I kind of dismissed as a weaker, more random Shadowcaster, but after mulling on it a bit, man, it's kind of awesome! It's kind of a build-around deck, isn't it?
  • The Curator: Well, this dude's insane. 7-mana, 4/6 Taunt... basically a single Twin Emperor that happens to be a Mech (which is pointless in Standard)... but it draws you a Dragon, a Beast and a Murloc. What insane breed of deck uses all three? I don't know, but the deck-building possibilities is kind of insane. There are a lot of great Dragon and Beast decks out there, and Murloc decks are... doable... but one that uses all three? It'll be hilarious and awesome when a proper triple tribe deck eventually gets made, but until then this is just a cool and initially seemingly-gimmicky card. What it is, though, is a Tutor card with an immediate effect -- anyone who's played a different TCG would know the sheer power of Tutor cards, which are cards that draw specific cards from your deck. Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh and Pokemon have a crapton of these as the backbone of their meta decks, and the closest that Hearthstone has to a Tutor card is Ancient Harbinger and she kind of is shit. Yes, the Curator doesn't draw your game-ending C'Thun... but the fact that she draws a dragon? You know Malygos decks? Yeah, they have a way to pull the big blue crazy old dragon out of their deck reliably. Alexstrasza in Freeze Mages? They get a Taunt and a guaranteed Alexstrasza in their hands. And even then, any Reno or Control deck will be happy to draw a Ysera, an Azure Drake, a Twilight Guardian, et cetera. The Beast portion might be more specific to Druid and Hunter decks, and I can't think of any super-combo-y Beast that I would want, but on the other hand an extra card in your hand can't really hurt. Murlocs... eh. Murloc Knight's the only real great Murloc I would want late-game, or maybe Corrupted Seer, and that's kinda iffy, but I suppose other Reno decks can fit in Bluegill Warrior? He's the only one I can see throwing into non-Murloc decks.

Ivory Knight(42019).png
Overall I liked the feel of the set. It doesn't feel too good from a meta standpoint, not the way that Whispers of the Old Gods had with the dual factor of rotating out two card blocks and introducing a lot of great build-around cards... but I dunno. This just feels fun. Also give Priest a bit of a bone, yeah, and give them some good minions and/or spells? Priest really should be about healing and unkillable minions as opposed to 'remove everything from the enemy's board by stealing or one-shotting them with a spell'.

Thursday, 19 May 2016

Hearthstone: Whispers of the Old Gods Full Set Review

 So yeah, I'm talking about Hearthstone here, I guess. It's a game dear to my heart, mostly because Warcraft III was such a huge part of me growing up. I used to talk about Hearthstone in a gaming sideblog but that kinda withered up and died, so my halfway-done project of reviewing the newest set, Whispers of the Old Gods, ended up being unposted and unfinished. Well, no sense leaving it to waste. I revised it after the metagame had settled down a little, and here we go. Obviously, placed behind a page break so it doesn't take like a titanic chunk of the blog for those who scroll down.



Wednesday, 11 May 2016

Well...

Well, I dunno. This blog isn't really working out with like an abysmal amount of views, so any Hearthstone-related posts I'll make will end up on my main blog (blackjackrants.blogspot.com). I'll probably still post the card dialogue/description/gallery lists here every half-year or whenever a new block of cards comes out, but my initial plan for this side blog, which is to make gaming-related content like let's plays and Warcraft lore things ended up not really panning out.

So, um. Yeah. Very little people will see this post, and I may or may not delete the blog altogether. But it was fun while it lasted.

Tuesday, 15 March 2016

Whispers of the Old Gods -- Early Card Reviews


I’m not sure how regularly I can be doing this, since as my main review blog states, real life is a bitch right now and I can’t even get a lot of reviews out in a timely manner. This was actually a small project started off near the start of the expansion’s announcement, but got kind of delayed. Oh well. Whatever the case, I’m reviewing the 8 or so cards that have been revealed. Sometimes I wish that Blizzard didn’t reveal all 150 or whatever cards before the expansion is released so there would be a couple of surprises in there and people won’t just be ‘time to craft that super-awesome-sounding deck that we’ve made a month before the expansion hits’ and all that. But eh, that’s how Blizzard rolls.

Honestly there’s not much that have been released, and out of the ones that we do get most of them have been somewhat underwhelming. It’s not quite TGT-level of underwhelming, though, because without seeing the true scope of the WOTOG expansion (that’s a mouthful, WOTOG, and probably could be an Old God’s name itself) and getting a feel of a Naxxramas-less, GvG-less metagame, it would be kind of easy to just dismiss the m’eh-looking cards before realizing that, hey, alongside the TGT cards, suddenly some of the previously average-level or above-average-but-not-quite-good-enough cards might actually be the new viable option.

Also, a couple smaller announcements with the new patch: it crashes on Android and turns your device screen pink, they’ve added 9 extra deck slots, a little deckbuilder help to create a bunch of pre-made archetypes, a new Paladin hero skin (Liadrin, unlocked if you get a level 20 WoW character) and pre-orders for the WOTOG expansion.


Anyway, quick card reviews:

·       Polluted Hoarder: One of the themes of the expansion is the ‘corruption’ of classic cards, making them far more powerful or generally just similar-but-different. Because corruption by the Great Elder Ones will bestow you power at the cost of madness and all that. Polluted (Po-Loot-ed, get it?) Hoarder, is, obviously, a simple scaled-up Loot Hoarder. It’s still got its old Deathrattle of drawing a card, but is a 4-mana 4/2, a simple scale-up from Loot Hoarder’s 2-mana 2/1. He’s definitely a viable 4-mana drop, especially in Arena when you’re not too picky as long as the card is solid. Now the question is, where to fit it? Piloted Shredder may be going out of rotation, but when is Polluted Hoarder more advantageous, than, say, a Chillwind Yeti or a Cult Master? It’s an interesting card, that’s for sure, one that helps decks that want to draw cards, and the 4 attack certainly makes it far more punishing to ignore than a Loot Hoarder. Not sure that it’s actually good in Constructed, but it’s definitely a decent card. Of course, that’s what I said about half the TGT set, and not a lot of them are played right now.

·       Validated Doomsayer: Other than its initial statline and its happy artwork, the Validated Doomsayer has little in common with its Classic namesake. The Validated Doomsayer is a 5-mana 0/7… which will gain 7 attack on the start of your next turn. You don’t attack until the second turn anyway, so hide this behind a Taunt or a Conceal and you get a 5-mana 7/7, which is insane value and far more stable than the likes of Fel Reaver, Anima Golem or Eerie Statue. The problem is, well, it’s particularly vulnerable to silence, if you don’t have means of protection your enemy’s minions can just smack its face and kill it with no damage to them and it’s vulnerable to Shadow Word: Pain. Of course, though, that all depends if your enemy has a counter to the Validated Doomsayer. I like this card. Not sure if it’s really that good, but it’s unique and fun.

·       Corrupted Healbot: The Ancient Healbot is angry that it is going out of rotation, so it went all rambo, got a couple of guns and tentacles and heals your enemy instead. The Corrupted Healbot is a 5-mana 6/6 that restores 8 health to the enemy hero… which is honestly quite bad. It’s decent in a control-heavy deck, of course, but the statline of 6/6 isn’t quite worth the disadvantage. 6/7 or 7/6 (Venture Co Mercenary and Boulderfist Ogre, respectively), maybe, but 6/6 is just m’eh. Hell, Pit Fighter is just one attack below this for the same cost and no disadvantage – and no, the Mech tag isn’t worth a damn since all the GvG cards are gone. Zombie Chow gets away with healing the opponent hero it because it’s a 1-drop with stats of a 2-drop, and it’s liable to die in the early turns where your enemy isn’t damaged anyway. Corrupted Healbot probably isn’t going to be very useful in decks other than gimmicky Auchenai Priest decks, where it will deal 8 damage to your enemy’s face which is insane.

·       Hogger, Doom of Elwynn: Hogger on steroids! Henceforth known as Doom Hogger because I don’t want to type that long-ass name, Doom Hogger makes me happy because this means that alternate versions of the same character can be turned into cards. That gives me hope for freaking Illidan Stormrage getting a properly good card, or alternate versions of, say, Arthas Menethil as a Paladin and as a Lich King. The original Hogger is a 6-mana 4/4 that summons a 2/2 Gnoll with Taunt at the end of each turn. Doom Hogger also summons 2/2 Gnoll, but does so every time it is damaged. It’s a 7-mana 6/6, which is significantly harder to kill. It may not be as devastating as Dr. Boom, obviously, but on paper it’s definitely better than the original Hogger. It plays to an enrage-style deck, though for obvious reasons it’s not quite as spammable as a Grim Patron. Things like Cruel Taskmaster, Wild Pyromancer and Whirlwind all trigger Doom Hogger. Warrior may be losing Death’s Bite and Unstable Ghoul, but there’s a lot that can trigger Doom Hogger to spawn a bunch of little Taunt dudes… and the dream, of course, is to Bolster them. It’s definitely better than Troggzor, which relies on your opponent casting a spell – who’s going to do that, really? Whereas you can proc Doom Hogger on your own. That said, though, I think Doom Hogger is going to be one of those ‘good, but average’ legendaries like Toshley or Gruul if you don’t have anything for that slot. Besides, y’know, Cthulhu Hogger! How can you not love that?

·       Eater of Secrets: Look at that skinny Faceless One. Eater of Secrets is a 4-mana 2/4, that destroys your enemy’s secrets and gains +1/+1 for each one destroyed. It’s kind of shit if you’re facing a non-Secret deck, since 4-mana 2/4 is, well, freaking terrible. But against Mage and Hunter decks with secrets it can be a 3/5 or even a 4/6, and as if Mysterious Challenger Secret Paladins aren’t punished enough with losing Avenge, you can drop a 4-mana 6/8 and destroy all their secrets without triggering them and starting off a stupid chain reaction. This rather cleverly also stopgaps Mysterious Challenger in Wild Mode without having to nerf the card itself. Otherwise, though, it’s extremely underwhelming. Maybe if its base stats was 3/4 or if it’s a 3-mana… but then it might be too much of an overkill against Secret Pallies? I dunno. With Kezan Mystic out of the rotation it’s nice to have another anti-Secret card that isn’t just a rehash.

·       Beckoner of Evil: The first of… nine? Twelve? Cards in the expansion that’ll interact with C’Thun, the Beckoner of Evil is a simple 2-mana 2/3 (River Crocolisk) with the battlecry of giving C’Thun +2/+2… wherever it is. See, the gimmick of C’Thun is that it gains power as its cultists summon it to the world, just like the Lovecraftian old gods, who slowly awake from their slumber when summoned by cultists. C’Thun gains the buff wherever it is. In your deck, in your hand, in the field… even [i]dead[/i]. The Beckoner seems extremely simple, and we’ll see if she’s actually really weak compared to the other C’Thun synergy cards, but to note is, well, she will give C’Thun +4/+4 with Brann Bronzebeard for a mere 2 mana. I think Brann would probably be an auto include in all C’Thun decks for that fact alone.

·       Twilight Elder: Gnomes be insane! Twilight Elder is a 3-mana 3/4 (Spider Tank), again, like the Beckoner, not a bad statline. It gives C’Thun +1/+1 wherever it is at the end of turn, so, um, yeah, drop a Stealth on this crazy gnome and C’Thun can just grow so wildly out of control. If you play this on curve it’s likely to survive at least a turn or two and it’s still a valuable body on its own, so yay for that!

·       C’Thun: So you buff your C’Thun with Twilight Elder, Beckoner of Evil and whatever other cards we haven’t seen yet. What, then? C’Thun is a 10-mana 6/6 that gains buffs from its cultists… and upon entry launches its attack value randomly upon all enemies. Like Avenging Wrath, but more Cthulhu. Obviously bad against a field with Doom Hogger or Frothing Berserker or Gurubashi Berserker, but, y’know, C’Thun himself will probably drop on the battlefield like a 10/10 or just something freakingly huge if you play your cards right and combo them with things like Brann or the Brewmasters to stack up those buffs. And if you have your Brann still alive on turn 10… that’s easily twenty-plus damage just launched like an airstrike all over your enemy. Until we see all the other C’Thun support cards it’s hard to judge him, but come on, you get a motherfucking Elder God for free. Like literally free. He’s definitely potentially strong enough to stand against the meta, especially if that twatty Big Game Hunter (a.k.a. Mr. No-Fun) gets nerfed. I’m not sure if Silences work on C’Thun, though, since they did say that the buff stacks with the player. I’m honestly just happy to see a playstyle that kind of builds around a single card specifically.

·       Stand Against Darkness: Muster for Battle’s big brother, Stand Against Darkness is a five-mana summon five tokens. Which is… a bit worse than Muster for Battle. And the Silver Hand Recruits aren’t that good now that Quartermaster is kind of gone out of rotation. It’s not a bad card, of course, and the amount of hate it receives in some forums is unwarranted. It’s a decent turn 5 play, and Silver Hand Recruits are good to trigger things like Avenge or be targets of buffs like Keeper of Uldaman or Blessing of Kings, but at the end of the day I would rather spend five mana on a proper minion. Yes, Loatheb, Ancient Healbot and Sludge Belcher are out, but there are definitely some better five-drops out there. Maybe Validated Doomsayer or Corrupted Healbot? We’ll see.

·       Giant Sandworm: An 8-mana 8/8 Beast that… can attack again if it kills another minion. Not a difficult task with 8 attack, so it means that the Giant Sandworm can just hit your enemy’s entire board and wipe it out so long as it retains health. And with things like Stablemaster and Bestial Wrath – both criminally underused cards that gives a Beast immune for a turn – the Giant Sandworm can basically clear out an entire board and attack your enemy’s face for 8 damage for no damage to itself, provided there isn’t anything with more than 8 health. Yes, this single beaked worm can literally wipe out an entire board of Molten Giants and Mountain Giants with the help of a single 1-mana spell (which no one remembers exists, I bet). It’s a cool card! I can see people actually making decks to help support the Sandworm, and it’s definitely a cool gimmick that I’m sure to try at least once.

·       Klaxxi Amber-Weaver: Oh, hey, look, our first Mantid card! The Mantids are one of the villains in the Mists of Pandaria storyline, and while they're nowhere as prominent or story-important as Garrosh Hellscream, the Mo'gu or the Sha, the Mantids are still connected to the Old Gods, specifically Y'shaarj. I think (not 100% sure) that the Klaxxi are actually the obligatory 'rebels' that fight against their Old GOd serving brethren, all Drizzt Do'urden and shit. The Amber-Weaver is a four-mana 4/5, basically your bog-standard Chillwind Yeti... with the potential to become a 4/10 if C'Thun has 10 attack by the time you summon the Klaxxi. This probably looks odd at a glance, but I'd argue that the Amber-Weaver might be one of the best cards in the ones that has been so far been revealed, that the only saving grace it has for the sake of balance is that it's in Druid. It's extremely unlikely to give C'Thun 10 attack by turn four if we go by the amount of cards that have been revealed, but you don't have to play the Klaxxi Amber-Weaver at turn 4. There's a bit of flexibility where you can wait for C'Thun to give the Weaver its value and have this card sit out in your hand for a bit, until you can drop this and maybe a different four-drop on turn 8 or something. But dropping it on turn 4 doesn't necessarily make you sad either, because, hey, worst case scenario you get a Yeti, which is a perfectly fine body. It's not something like, oh, Gormok or Kezan Mystic or the 'if you're holding a Dragon' cards where you get a bit penalized stat-wise if you don't meet the requirements. You don't have a 10-attack C'Thun? No problem, have a cool-looking bug Yeti! And it's far from being game-breaking either. Four mana 4/10 is great value, but it's not that insane in Druid. It's safe from Shadow Word X shenanigans, but still vulnerable to Silences. Gamebreaking it ain't, but damn it's a fun-looking card.

Overall it's interesting. I wished they had gone with more Old God and Faceless One cards to help ease the theme of Old Gods more instead of 'let's corrupt and twist some old favourites', but we've seen like less than 5% of the expansion, so it's way too early for the naysayers who think that this is just pushing reprints for money, plus people who hate the idea of Standard Mode. It's definitely far more invigorating than TGT was at this stage in time, though, again, we'll see how good the whole expansion ends up being as more and more cards are shown.